Girls’ Phobia on ICT: Reality or Perception?

“Have you ever been taught by an ICT teacher which is women? The result is 1:4 for the respondents who say yes oppose to say no.”

     In the early years of the Internet, the typical user was young, male and most likely to be American. In the last ten years, the picture has changed significantly, with women representing a larger proportion of internet users, at a range of different ages. However there is still concern among both governments and the ICT industry that most of girls are ICT Phobia – is this reality, or just perception?

ICT activities: boys vs girls

Research reveals that girls and women use computer technology widely but in different ways to boys and men. DiDio (1996) and Brimmer (1997) found that girls use ICT for social reasons such as chatting and meeting people whereas boys tend to be more interested in playing games, hacking and learning about technology.  Girls are keener on creative technologies for artistic expression.

Educational achievement in ICT between girls and boys

There is very little difference between boys and girls in terms of achievement in ICT studies, although their self-perception is different. Girls tend to understate their skills whereas boys usually overestimate their competence. It is according to a research conducted by Infodev on “Women and ICT: Why are girls still not attracted to ICT studies and careers?” at secondary school level.

Girls often report that they enjoy studying ICT. In countries where girl is not enjoy studying ICT, it is typically due to an over-emphasis on pure programming skills in the curriculum which is kind of programming which is typically less attractive to girls compared to e.g. multimedia skills.

The causes of the problem

Girls, compared to boys, are more influenced by role models in their environment whether ‘close’ role models such as parents, teachers and family or ‘distant’ role models such as famous actresses and musicians. It is clear that the lack of ICT oriented role models is a discouraging factor for girls.

Another key issue is that parents, school guidance counselors and teachers lack knowledge of ICT studies and careers: they thus do not encourage students who express interest in such areas, as they perceive ICT as a field where there are good career opportunities for girls.

How ICT subjects are taught in schools also has a major impact on girls’ attitudes towards these subjects, according to Newmarch, Taylor-Steele and Cumpston (2000) who found that girls considered ICT subjects to be too theoretical, rigidly structured and boring. Girls in the study commented that they found working on individual projects to be less rewarding and satisfying than working on group projects.

The interesting point is that some popular movie show women actively engaged with computer technology depict them as encountering danger or harassment as a result of their technology use. For example, Sandra Bullock in The Net and Sigourney Weaver in Copycat are both victimized on account of their use of computers (Rowan, Knobel, Bigum and Lankshear, 2002).

What can teachers do?

·        Introduce students to a wide variety of computing applications in order to develop an appreciation of the possible uses of computers (e.g. using ICT tools as part of language lessons).

·        Dispel inaccurate images of computers and IT careers through direct experience with positive role models. schools (e.g. through inviting guest speakers in schools, or visiting local IT company facilities/university departments).

·         Explain explicitly to students the connections between ICT subject content and the world of work.

·         Integrate computer use across the curriculum to invite more girls into technology through a broad range of subjects.

·        Communicate to students the information that all jobs in the future will involve the use of more and more ICT.

·         Challenge and critique stereotypes about gender and ICT, involve more female IT professionals and female IT students in careers activities

·        Build informal ICT activities, such as computer clubs, alongside the school curriculum that give young people the space to ‘play’ with ICT.